Best of 13 Italian restaurants in Markham

Indulge in the culinary delights of Kara Mia, where each pasta dish is a celebration of rich sauces and succulent meats that dance on your palate. While some diners have encountered hiccups with new servers, the majority rave about the accommodating and cheerful staff who elevate your dining experience. The inviting ambiance complements the reasonably priced menu, making every visit feel like a special occasion.



Although the chicken parmesan may not steal the spotlight, the steak with peppercorn sauce and the saffron-infused steak are nothing short of spectacular, leaving a lasting impression that will have you craving more. At Kara Mia, every meal is crafted to create unforgettable memories, inviting you to savor the perfect blend of flavor and warmth that only a truly exceptional restaurant can offer.

Our summer evenings at Novati’s patio were nothing short of enchanting. With its bright, airy atmosphere and ample parking, the restaurant exudes a welcoming charm. We opted for the tiered seating, perfect for an intimate gathering or a private celebration. As we settled in with our group, including an 87-year-old family member, we were eager to unwind after the holiday hustle. However, our experience was slightly marred by an overly attentive server who rushed us through drink orders, interrupting our relaxed vibe.



Despite the initial hiccup, the culinary offerings at Novati’s were impressive, showcasing the rich flavors of Italian cuisine. The food was delectable enough to entice us to return, perhaps for a more leisurely experience. With its spacious layout and inviting ambiance, this Markham gem has the potential to become a cherished dining spot for our family, where we can savor every moment together.

Indulge in a culinary experience where every bite bursts with freshness and savory delight, all expertly cooked to al dente perfection. While some diners note the portions may be on the petite side and prices slightly elevated, the overall dining experience is undeniably memorable. For those who savor quality over quantity, each dish promises to tantalize your taste buds and leave you yearning for more.



As we settled into our seats, our waiter greeted us with a warm familiarity, exclaiming, "Ohhh, I know you guys!" His genuine enthusiasm and uncanny memory of our previous order—two rigatonis—spoke volumes about the exceptional service that sets this restaurant apart. It’s this personal touch that transforms a simple meal into an unforgettable occasion, ensuring that every visit feels like a cherished reunion.

Indulge your senses at this charming gem on Markham Main Street, where culinary delights and exceptional service come together in perfect harmony. Savor every bite of the exquisite calamari fritte, perfectly crispy and bursting with flavor, paired with a delightful glass of red that elevates your dining experience to new heights. The warm and welcoming staff are not just attentive; they make you feel like part of the family, ensuring your visit is nothing short of memorable.



As you explore the menu, let your taste buds dance with joy at the tantalizing grilled octopus and the savory chicken spaghetti, each dish crafted with care and bursting with flavor. This cozy spot is more than just a restaurant; it’s a celebration of delicious food and genuine hospitality, inviting you to return time and again for an unforgettable culinary adventure.

Indulge in a culinary experience that transcends the ordinary at this vibrant dining destination! During my visit in September 2019, I was swept away by the lively ambiance and tantalizing flavors that danced on my palate. The energy of the place was infectious, with a soundtrack of lively music enhancing the overall experience. Each dish was a masterpiece, expertly crafted and bursting with flavor, making every bite a celebration of fine dining.



The service was impeccable, with attentive staff who seemed to anticipate my every need, ensuring a seamless evening of gastronomic delight. This restaurant is not just a meal; it’s an unforgettable journey that captivates the senses and leaves a lasting impression. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or simply treating yourself, this is the perfect spot to savor exquisite cuisine in an atmosphere that truly sparkles.

Milano's Grill is a culinary gem that beckons with its enticing menu and irresistible daily specials. Indulge in mouthwatering favorites like the crispy fish n' chips or the succulent beef Philly, each dish crafted to perfection and served piping hot. The grilled chicken souvlaki and gyro sandwich are crowd-pleasers, delighting palates with their bold flavors and generous portions—all at wallet-friendly prices that make dining out a pleasure.



With a commendable 4.3 rating on Google, this vibrant eatery is celebrated not just for its delectable fare but also for its warm, welcoming ambiance. Guests rave about the attentive service, where the friendly staff embodies the spirit of Milano's Grill. Whether you're enjoying a casual meal with friends or a cozy dinner date, the inviting atmosphere makes every visit a memorable experience. Discover your new favorite spot today!

Indulge in a culinary experience that won’t break the bank, where generous portions and wallet-friendly prices come together in perfect harmony. The garlic bread, a true delight, is simply fantastic—golden and toasted to perfection, it’s the ideal starter to whet your appetite for the main event.



Step into a vibrant atmosphere that buzzes with excitement, where every bite of delicious pizza transports you to pizza paradise. The pepperoni pizza is an absolute must-try, boasting a perfect blend of savory toppings and a crispy crust that will leave you craving more. Treat yourself to this slice of heaven; you won’t regret it!

Step into Porta Via Restaurant, where the essence of Italy comes alive in every bite. Indulge in a mouthwatering selection of Italian-inspired sandwiches and paninis that promise to tantalize your taste buds. The Grilled Veggie Panini, paired with a rich and comforting Tomato Soup, is a must-try that will leave you craving more. Each dish is crafted with passion, ensuring a delightful experience for every guest.



But the culinary journey doesn't stop there! Porta Via also caters to diverse palates with an array of vegan and vegetarian delights. Among the crowd favorites is the Prosciutto & Brie Panini, a harmonious blend of savory and creamy flavors that patrons can't resist. Whether you're a devoted foodie or simply looking for a satisfying meal, Porta Via invites you to savor the authentic tastes of Italy right in your neighborhood.

Discover the hidden gem of the area, where culinary delights meet an unforgettable atmosphere! This charming Italian restaurant is a feast for the senses, boasting not only mouthwatering dishes but also an ambiance that wraps you in warmth. The owner, Sebastian, radiates hospitality, ensuring every visit feels like coming home. With meticulous attention to detail, he and his team create a dining experience that goes above and beyond.



As you step inside, the cozy intimacy envelops you, making it the perfect spot for a romantic dinner or a gathering with friends. Enjoy a slice of heaven with their delectable pizza, crafted to perfection and bursting with flavor. The enchanting melodies of Italian music fill the air, enhancing the experience and transporting you straight to Italy. Indulge in this delightful escape—where exceptional food and service come together in harmony!

The aged steak, unfortunately, missed the mark with its uneven cooking, while the Angus steak didn’t quite deliver the flavor we had hoped for. The gnocchi and ragu fell flat, lacking the robust taste that should ignite the palate. However, the charcuterie board stood out, offering a delightful array of flavors that tantalized our taste buds and provided a glimmer of hope amidst the culinary disappointments.



To add a personal touch to our celebration, we brought a small birthday cake, only to be met with an unexpected $4 per person fee to enjoy our own dessert. The main dishes arrived disappointingly cold, following the salad and shared plates, leaving us yearning for a warmer, more inviting dining experience. In a world where every meal should be a celebration, this one left us craving something more.

Nestled within the charming Monte Carlo Inn, this delightful restaurant offers a warm and inviting atmosphere perfect for a family gathering. As we stepped inside, the friendly reception staff greeted us with genuine smiles, setting the tone for a wonderful dining experience. The menu features a tantalizing fusion of Western cuisine infused with Hong Kong flair, and the star of the show is undoubtedly the honey mustard pork chop—a dish that I confidently proclaim as the best in town. Juicy and bursting with flavor, it’s a culinary masterpiece that promises to leave your taste buds dancing with delight.



The generous portions and exceptional service from the attentive staff make every visit feel special, ensuring you feel right at home. While the Christmas dinner menu is a bit pricier than usual, the exquisite flavors and festive ambiance make it worth every penny. Whether you're celebrating a special occasion or simply enjoying a weekend lunch, this hidden gem will undoubtedly impress with its delightful dishes and warm hospitality.

Indulge in a slice of heaven at this charming family-run Italian restaurant, where every bite of their fresh, authentic pizza transports you straight to the heart of Italy. With generous toppings that burst with flavor and a dough that's perfectly crafted, each pizza is a delightful masterpiece. The rich, savory sauce complements the ingredients beautifully, making every mouthful a satisfying experience that lingers on your palate.



But the culinary journey doesn’t stop there; their top-notch pasta is equally irresistible, crafted with passion and tradition. Settle into the cozy ambiance, where warmth and hospitality embrace you, and savor the delectable dishes that promise to turn your meal into a cherished memory. Whether you're a pizza aficionado or a pasta lover, this gem is a must-visit for an unforgettable dining experience!

From the moment we stepped into the restaurant, the warmth exuded by Manager Jenna and Chef Randy transformed our menu tasting into an enchanting culinary journey. Their meticulous attention to detail enveloped us in an atmosphere that felt like a cozy family gathering, reminiscent of dining at a beloved home. Time and again, this gem has welcomed our family, and during this visit, servers Katie and Liza elevated our experience with their exceptional service and delectable dishes. Each bite was a celebration of flavor, making it impossible not to recommend this delightful spot to anyone in the area.



Our evening was nothing short of magical, thanks to the friendly staff and the enchanting ambiance, complete with the perfect soundtrack. Despite initial reservations based on mixed reviews, we were pleasantly surprised by the outstanding quality of both food and service. Jenna’s engaging personality and spot-on recommendations turned our meal into a delightful adventure. With every visit, this restaurant solidifies its place as a must-visit destination, and we can’t wait to return for more memorable moments.